News 
 State News 
 Livestock 
 Cattle 
 BSE stoush: Heatley returns serve at Heffernan 

BSE stoush: Heatley returns serve at Heffernan

05 Mar, 2010 03:04 PM
MEAT and Livestock Australia (MLA) boss Don Heatley has lashed out at Coalition Senators for jeopardising the future of Australia’s beef industry.

Mr Heatley blasted the Coalition’s stance on newly relaxed beef import rules during an AgForce red meat industry forum in Gayndah today (Friday).

His comments come as Coalition Senators led by Nationals Barnaby Joyce and Fiona Nash and Liberal Senator Bill Heffernan attempt to reverse the Rudd Government’s decision allowing the controlled entry of red meat from the US, a country previously detected with BSE or mad cow disease.

Mr Heatley said those politicians attempting to land punches on the Rudd Government by trashing the reputation of Australian beef with claims it was unsafe to eat were neglecting their duty as national leaders.

“The mischievous nature of our politicians, who are too busy enhancing their own careers instead of doing their jobs and asking common sense questions of the industry on this issue, has gotten way out of hand,” he said.

“I am a proud cattle producer and it really browns me off to see these politicians hold my industry – your industry – to ransom with their posturing. It’s just garbage.”

Mr Heatley said Senator Heffernan’s true agenda was not to tighten import protocols but to totally halt US beef imports, previously a paltry 34 tonnes compared to the 300,000 tonnes Australia exports to the US each year.

Mr Heatley said stopping imports would spark retaliatory action from our trading partners, especially if one case of BSE was ever detected in the Australian herd.

“Watch out for Senator Heffernan because what he wants to do is stop US beef imports, end of story. I can tell you that is not in our interests,” Mr Heatley said.

“We need to be arguing on the science and the science on both sides of the Pacific tells me that US beef is safe. We don’t need to be making decisions based on emotion.”

Earlier, people at the meeting heard from Queensland’s top government vet Ron Glanville dismiss BSE concerns, explaining there was “virtually zero risk” to the public and a negligible risk of detecting BSE in the Australian herd.

The meeting of 100 cattle producers and industry figures comes one week after several hundred angry farmers gathered in Armidale to protest changes to Australia’s beef import rules.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Mr Heatley, it may have been a paltry 34 tonne, prior to the BSE out break, and only from US, but am I not right in saying if anyone from any country in the world meets the new imort laws, they too can export beef to Aust? And it's stated virtually zero risk of BSE entering Australia, I think it could also be said we have virtually zero risk of having BSE in Aust. Why would you jeopardise our long-term beef production in Aust? PS didn't attend the meeting in Armidale, but congratulations to them for letting the voice of the beef producers be heard, instead of having to put up with MLA who no longer listen to the producer.
Posted by tj, 5/03/2010 3:21:14 PM, on Queensland Country Life
I have read all the comments by Heffernan, Nash & Joyce and not once have I heard them rubbishing Australia beef. To the contrary we have only heard them talk up our clean, green and traceability compared to the rubbish that might come in if this proposal gets up from Heatley and McIvor and their Labor cronies. This means Crean, Burke and Roxton. It is a long time since M.L.A., Cattle Council and Red Meat Advisory Council represented the people who pay their wages.
Posted by Brenda & John, 5/03/2010 4:38:55 PM, on Queensland Country Life
These boys in opposition are the same fellows happy to pay Saddam to take our grain then go and kill the poor buggar. These are the same men who have no regard for the beef industry only regard to their own re-election. There was more chance of being killed in Iraq than hurt from BSE - a lot more chance in fact even if you never go there. Stop giving them media air time.
Posted by william hayes, 5/03/2010 4:45:25 PM, on Queensland Country Life
RMAC, AgForce and the lot of them want horse whipping for not widely consulting with grass roots producers before taking the BSE policy to government. They are arrogant and take their membership for granted. Wake up and consult and avoid what you have caused. You will regret your folly.
Posted by Sweeney, 5/03/2010 4:59:22 PM, on Queensland Country Life
I'm sorry Mr Heatley, it is MLA and the government jeopardising the beef industry (and many other industries) in Australia by adding so many costs (NLIS) (cattle transaction levies) and by signing the free trade agreement with the USA and the side letter relating to BSE. Please go away and read the Sydney Morning Herald of 3/3/10 in realtion to the free trade agreement with the USA. It is the FTA and the side letter that is causing the current problems, not the Senators supporting beef producers in Australia. You Mr Heatley and MLA and CC, government employees who sat back and agreed with government policy, are the ones who created the current problem. Don't try and blame a politician for your own lack of action and foresight into these matters.
Posted by Archibald, 5/03/2010 5:02:53 PM, on Queensland Country Life
I was at the meeting at Armidale and I thought it was appalling. I was less than impressed with Alan Jones as chairman, with the way he conducted the meeting, but what would you expect from a radio shock jock who is being paid to do the job of chairman. I am saddened that some beef producers are being a party to sullying the name of our great beef industry in Australia with scaremongering to air old grievances and score points.
Posted by Ernest, 6/03/2010 11:17:16 AM, on Queensland Country Life
If it was only 34 tons, what's the big deal about letting it back in??? Why not keep it out! The arguement goes both ways! Since 2003 we have had the implementation of NLIS, as we have upgraded our traceback, I think its only fair that those wishing to export to us have to upgrade theres too! Sorry Heatley, don't agree with you at all, and who said you should represent the beef producers of Australia, you certainly DO NOT represent MY VIEW! Why would BSE ever be found in Australia if we protect our borders appropriately? Isn't that what this is all about?? DUH? Or do you have some other agenda also? It's open slather on fruit, vegies, pork and it's killed those industries; is beef the final fronteer? We now import milk powder from China that goes into most of our dairy products, ice-cream without real milk, where to next? Powdered beef (reconstituted) in our Big Macs? It's only killing Australian beef because some-one opened the door and it's made the consumers nervous. Why? Because they are not sure what is Australian beef BECAUSE THERE IS NO LABEL!!!!!!! They would still be happy to buy Aussie beef but as they can't differentiate they will opt for NO BEEF! I would too!
Posted by no joke, 7/03/2010 2:17:09 AM, on Queensland Country Life
I agree with Heatley- a man who has some responsibility and duty of care towards his industry. I would never agree with Joyce or Heffernan. Who are both a sad indictment to the state of Australia's politics and have no cares except their own. Keep dumbing down boys because thats what you are mere boys. As for Bindaree, BSE and "Helicopter" Alan Jones .... sad that they get the attention. As for "no joke" you need to realise how far free trade has gotten Australia so far.
Posted by Ocky mura, 7/03/2010 7:45:23 PM, on Queensland Country Life
The BSE debate is about perception a bit like NLIS where we pretend we have lifetime tracability we all know including Don Heatley that we don't. Why don't we have inspections of USA abattoirs like EU have with ours.Former MLA chaiman David Crombie was only interested in the big end of town,but Don i thought there was light at the end of the tunnel with you but you've gone down that same track.Why can't every producer who pays a levy know matter how many cattle he sells automaticaly receive voting rights without having to register with MLA,if NLIS is so good the data base should have the number every LEVY PAYER has sold. It's a mates club you get the same one's getting research & develpment money.RMAC,MLA,CCA,AGFORCE it,s just one big happy family,ooh and the QCL they are like glue,never a desent against each other anyone who has a another opinion is a rebel or causing trouble,take the hint you blokes we,ve had enough we want to be more involved in decision making.
Posted by les, 7/03/2010 8:12:44 PM, on Queensland Country Life
Hey les if you don't like the result from the people involved in the current structure why don't you get involved and make your point of view mean something? Hang on, much easier to go with a heady mix of half truths, fear and religion to save the world - go the JR cult!
Posted by Qld taxpayer and JR funder, 8/03/2010 7:17:30 AM, on Queensland Country Life
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
MLA chairman Don Heatley
MLA chairman Don Heatley
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
POLL
Q: What do you think the outlook for your commodity will be this year?

Highly positive
(6.1%)

Positive
(24%)

Neutral
(34.5%)

Negative
(23.3%)

Highly negative
(12.1%)

Total Votes: 429
Poll Date: 28 February, 2010
BLOGS
04 March, 2010

Most popular articles

ELDERS NEWS MREC SJ



Queensland Country Life







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...