News 
 State News 
 Horticulture 
 General 
 Woolworths warns banana concentration a recipe for disaster 

Woolworths warns banana concentration a recipe for disaster

02 Apr, 2009 03:15 PM
Supermarket giant, Woolworths, says the present concentration of Australia's banana industry in the Tully and Innisfail region of northern Queensland is a "potential recipe for disaster".

Michael Batycki, Woolies' national general manager for fresh foods, urged the industry to pursue a wider geographical spread of production or the next cyclone that devastated banana farms around Innisfail and Tully could open the door to import competition.

Mr Batycki said Woolworths intended to stick with its local suppliers despite Biosecurity Australia's recent decision to allow imports of cavendish bananas from the Philippines.

"We deal with a large number of growers in the Innisfail and Tully region and some other regions as well, including Humpty Doo (in the Northern Territory)," he said.

Woolworths wasn't in discussions with any Filipino banana suppliers nor had the company bothered to check the conditions under which imports would be allowed, Mr Batycki said.

He said Woolies was looking forward to doing good business with its trusted and proven Australian banana suppliers for many years to come and didn't see any need to import product.

But Mr Batycki said another Cyclone Larry, which devastated the Innisfail and Tully banana farms in 2006 and reduced the availability of bananas in Australian shops to an expensive trickle, could change things.

He said Larry's decimation of 90 to 95 percent of Australia's banana crop around Tully and Innisfail (about 12,500ha) had provided good reason for growers to seriously consider the advantages of spreading Australia's banana output into other regions.

Bananas were the number one seller in supermarket farm produce sections, he said, and the challenge for local growers was to supply fruit that was as good as or better than imported product.

And any lengthy disruption of local supplies would "expose" growers to the risk of import competition and more geographical diversity of production would help overcome this problem, Mr Batycki said.

Ironically, the local industry has bitterly opposed Filipino banana imports for the best part of a decade because of fears they could introduce diseases such as black sigatoka and moko that potentially could decimate production in Tully and Innisfail (and elsewhere) just as effectively as any cyclone.

Growers in the Tully Valley have managed to eradicate black sigatoka once before but fear they won't be so lucky again.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Fine, but when was the last time Woolworths paid a single cent extra in risk premium to less competitive NSW and SEQ banana growers to maintain both biosecurity and supply security? Answer: Never.

The chains dominate the market. They made all the choices that produced the current situation and now say, "Gee wiz, we have a problem".

People were telling them this 40 years ago.

Posted by Ian Mott, 3/04/2009 10:00:32 AM
Great suggestion but people, other than farmers, don't seem to realize that not all plants and crops can be grown in all climates.

Tully Valley and FNQ grow the best bananas in Australia, other bananas are no where near the same quality. Bananas are badly affected by frost and don't like cold weather, prefer coastal conditions, don't mind rain but hate dry and hot. They can only be grown in certain areas.

Same with all this "move north and grow our food there". Most of the food grown in the south cannot be grown in the north and visa versa. Come on scientists, report the facts.

Posted by Concerned Northerner, 3/04/2009 3:53:20 PM
Not a word of thanks or gratitude to Woolworths for their commitment to local banana growers? Where are all the grateful agrarian socialist banana growers? Why do they not offer a simple thank you? Probably all too busy whingeing about how the Australian population and Government doesn't understand their demand that we owe them a living by banning imports.
Posted by Rick O'Shay, 3/04/2009 6:22:18 PM
Far north QLD bananas are not the best or tastiest. The best bananas came from Northern NSW. This industry was virtually wiped out by the big supermarkets not buying the smaller sized fruit from this area.
Posted by Elleanor, 22/04/2009 12:09:23 PM
You guys blow your own horn as loud as you like, the debate is not about the best, just where they should be planted incase of another uncle Larry.....get it?

By the way, bananas are grown in Carnarvon WA - the rest of your regions grow flourey crap.

Councelling is available from me, you poor lost souls, stay cyclone free and all the best!!

Posted by winner, 4/11/2009 11:10:28 PM, on Queensland Country Life

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
02 April, 2009
01 April, 2009
POLL
Q: Are land clearing laws having a negative environmental impact on your property?

Yes
(67.7%)

No
(30%)

Other
(2.2%)

Total Votes: 496
Poll Date: 29 March, 2009

Most popular articles

SPRAY AWARDS NEWS MREC



Queensland Country Life







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...