News 
 State News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 Political 
 Qld Govt slams Abbott Wild Rivers law challenge 

Qld Govt slams Abbott Wild Rivers law challenge

13 Jan, 2010 09:25 AM
THE Queensland Government has criticised Federal Opposition Leader Tony Abbott's push to overturn its law protecting rivers in Cape York as a hypocritical stunt designed to win votes at the federal election.

The Federal Government said it would not support the private member's bill Mr Abbott plans to introduce into Parliament next month to quash Queensland's controversial wild rivers legislation.

Mr Abbott said the state law, which protects pristine waterways from development, denied Aboriginal people on the Cape economic opportunities.

''It's about locking up the land in ways which deny Aboriginal people their legitimate right to use it for their own benefit,'' Mr Abbott, who met indigenous leaders in Cairns yesterday, told the ABC.

But Queensland's Natural Resources Minister, Stephen Robertson, said: ''I can only think this is more about the next federal election and [the Liberals'] desire to win back the seat of Leichhardt than it is about any real concern about communities in Cape York.

''Any reasonable reading of the wild rivers legislation and the declarations of the Stewart, Lockhart and Archer rivers shows economic opportunities are hard-wired into those declarations.''

Despite claims by Cape York indigenous leader Noel Pearson to the contrary, the wild rivers legislation permits grazing, ecotourism, fishing, mining, aquaculture, animal husbandry and extracting water for community use on the Cape, subject to certain conditions. It also permits indigenous cultural activities.

A spokesperson for acting federal Environment Minister Penny Wong said: "The Government will continue to take practical steps, tied to concrete goals, to close the gap that exists between indigenous and non-indigenous Australians.''

The Greens also refused to back Mr Abbott's bill. "The Coalition's environment policy is two-pronged: refer national responsibilities, like World Heritage nominations, to the states, and override state legislation which protects nationally significant assets,'' Greens leader Bob Brown said. ''Both ways, Australia's wild natural heritage gets torpedoed."

The chairman of the Cape York Land Council, Richie Ahmat, said only a handful of the 10,000 Aborigines living on the Cape supported the wild rivers law. ''This is of grave concern … Our children have been locked out of sustainable development opportunities on their land for the sake of green votes in the city,'' he said.

The 2005 law was introduced in response to the Howard government's National Water Initiative, which required states to identify and protect high-conservation waterways.

Nineteen rivers, including the three on the Cape, were earmarked for preservation, and have been declared ''wild rivers''.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Noel Pearson is right, and so is Tony Abbott to back him, I know where my vote is going.
Posted by the ringer, 14/01/2010 4:51:30 AM, on Queensland Country Life
So which body of scientific evidence has concluded that a river system is irreparably harmed if even 5% or 10% of flood flows are captured for irrigation? Robertson sleazes on about eco-tourism and grazing still being allowed but the essence of "wild Rivers" is the complete prohibition of even the smallest diversions for irrigation. This is totally at variance with the whole concept of sustainability which demands a balance of economic, social and ecological values. But as far as these knuckle-dragging Labor Party neanderthals are concerned, their idea of balance is to gather all the money in the SE corner and heap all the ecological burdens onto the rest of the state. There is not a scrap of evidence in support of a total irrigation ban on any river, anywhere. Yes, in-stream dams have some downside, but if they were serious about protecting the Barrier Reef from silt then there is no better tool than an off-stream water storage.
Posted by Ian Mott, 14/01/2010 10:08:30 AM, on Queensland Country Life
Most of this recent round of the Wild Rivers debate all comes down to what the community knows and understands about what the Wild Rivers legislation will mean to them, their environment and their livelihoods in these catchments. Ignorance is bliss, but in this case it is also highly dangerous. So people, please make the effort to get to know the legislation before you start going off on ill-informed rants. The easiest things in the world to do is to criticise...but criticism without knowledge is very worrying. There is science around in relation to the impacts of irrigation. In fact, Blind Freddy can show you instances all around the world, and in the Murray-Darling Basin, to highlight the problems with irrigation. Closer to home, previous proposals for irrigation on the Cooper have used similar rhetoric of only 1-2% of the annual flow being used for irrigation. But again, if you know anything about the Cooper and other systems in central Australia, 1-2% for many years represents ALL the water. This newspaper has an important obligation to provide the facts and not to inflame the situation. Remember, knowledge is power...and maybe for Tony Abbott, ignorance IS bliss! :-)
Posted by jezza4, 16/01/2010 10:55:12 AM, on Queensland Country Life
Thank you Ian Mott, I don't think anyone could have said it better! I endorse everything you said. The day is going to come when we will need to dam some of the northern rivers of Qld to feed us. What then?
Posted by Trugger, 16/01/2010 8:13:48 PM, on Queensland Country Life

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Federal Opposition Leader Tony Abbott.
Federal Opposition Leader Tony Abbott.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES

Most popular articles

SPRAY AWARDS NEWS MREC



Queensland Country Life







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...