News 
 State News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 Political 
 Flood anger as disaster strikes again 

Flood anger as disaster strikes again

09 Feb, 2012 04:00 AM
THE irate mayor of the flood-damaged Balonne Shire wants to know why State Government authorities turned their back on her region and failed to help prepare for this year's flood disaster.

Mayor Donna Stewart says the lack of a permanent flood levee at St George and the closure of high-level access to Dirranbandi contributed to regional chaos caused by an inadequate State Government flood strategy.

As new permanent levees at Charleville and Augathella were credited with saving about a hundred million dollars in flood damage, residents at St George, Dirranbandi, Mitchell and other centres across the region were returning to devastated homes and businesses and a massive repair bill.

At Mitchell, the Warrego Highway is likely to remain cut to heavy transport for months while livestock shipments, interstate transport and the local economy are disrupted by the badly damaged road bridge. As mayors from across the southern inland assessed the damage, Ms Stewart blasted the Government for the multimillion-dollar cost of temporary measures, such as evacuations and earthworks, when wise investment could have averted the worst of the crisis.

"Why do we get their attention only when there is a disaster?" Ms Stewart asked. "Why are we not entitled to their attention all year long?

Ms Stewart said the town of Dirranbandi would remain cut off for two weeks or more because the state closed its high-level rail link to Thallon three years ago.

"The State Government is always on our backs about planning ? sustainability plans, community plans and all," she said. "Floods can occur in this part of Queensland and planning for them is a state responsibility.

"So where was their plan? They need to take a good, hard look at themselves."

Murweh Shire CEO Chris Blanch said residents at Charleville and Augathella were celebrating the success of their permanent levees, which saved homes, the local hospital, government facilities, businesses and infrastructure from damage.

"In Charleville, the '96 flood was about this size and it cost $80 million," he said. "In 2012, we saved that money.

"If Suncorp had paid for their construction, they'd have come out in front."

The cost of the Charleville and Augathella levees was shared among the council and State and Federal governments.

Maranoa Regional Mayor Rob Loughnan said building a flood-proof replacement for the Mitchell Bridge would have to proceed in "double quick time". "The Warrego Highway will end at Roma," he said. "The cattle industry west of Mitchell will be cut off from the Roma Saleyards. They will be trucking cattle south to Begonia and across to Roma on a dirt road. It will be an economic disaster for the whole region."

Mr Loughnan said another priority would be to transform a proposed permanent Roma flood levee from a recently completed plan into reality and to start a similar planning process at Mitchell. He thanked the Government for its design work. A total of 290 homes were inundated in Roma and 289 in Mitchell.

"We need to think about lifting the level of road access to the RSL, which is the evacuation centre at Mitchell, so that it cannot be cut off," he said.

Of 54 homes inundated at St George, Ms Stewart said all but a handful could have been saved if a council plan for a $3m permanent levee had been enacted.

"It was a plan for a wall to protect the town at river heights of up to 14.5 metres," she said. "It would have been right for the flooding we have seen."

Instead, the State Government paid twice for the construction of temporary levees in 2011 and 2012, as well as the hurried evacuation of St George residents via Moonie.

"I cannot even guess what all that has cost," she said. "If you ran a private business like that you'd be out the back door."

Ms Stewart said repeated flood events and damage to homes and infrastructure in Balonne and other council areas had not produced new flood gauges in the Maranoa River.

"We need better planning for permanent structures, not just band-aids when there is a disaster," she said.

"I was getting reports of homesteads upstream with water up to their eaves," she said. "These are places that have never been flooded before, but the Bureau of Meteorology could not predict a river height until the water reached Old Cashmere. That's a day away. What sort of warning is that?"

She said serious damage to cotton crops was caused when water from the Maranoa River broke into an old water course, the Gleer, west of St George.

"Last year, the Balonne Shire produced 600,000 bales of cotton," she said. "That's a big contribution to the national economy, worth about $500m.

Western Downs Regional Mayor, Ray Brown, said $90m worth of damage was caused to infrastructure across a large part of the council area by floods in 2010 and 2011, but the 2012 flood crisis was largely confined to its southern part.

He said flood crises such as the event at Condamine twelve months ago revealed the need for plans to provide every township with at least one high-level access route to ensure ready evacuation is always an option for residents.

"There has got to be a substantial increase in expenditure on rural roads," he said. "There is a huge agricultural sector out here and it is worth a lot of money. It is disturbing that after 10-12 years of drought, we have gone from one extreme to another.

"Every time there is a flood event, there are blockages in the network. We can't resupply our towns or get our produce to market. The energy sector is immobilized. The economy is the big loser. We should not spend our money on band-aids. We have to be smarter about the way our taxpayer's dollars are spent."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Why? Because they are a government of metrocentric morons with the attention span of an antechinus in rut, that s why.

All we can do is vote. And the only way the bush can rid itself of the threat posed by gullible urban voters is to put a new state boundary just north of Noosa and at the foot of the range.

Posted by Ian Mott, 9/02/2012 10:17:05 AM, on Queensland Country Life
Close family live in this great town, now cleaning out their home yet again. This house was never flooded before 2012 but these floods that come down systems already brimming are a different story to those following drought with empty waterholes & parched earth.

These towns need permanent protection from disaster. Barnaby J & Howard Hobbs have been onto this too. There would have been minimal extraction, if any, from these waters, in our more outback district the rivers east of us have had prolonged runs at near record levels & should reach the Darling. Might shut up the whingers to the south.

Posted by a GRAZIER, 10/02/2012 11:23:55 AM, on Queensland Country Life
Yeah, one decent flow down here in twenty years ain't bad is it Grazier?

Pity the environment can't adapt to one in twenty, when pre european it was one in three, in a blink of an eye.

Posted by fridgimus, 25/02/2012 8:14:12 PM, on Queensland Country Life

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Floods rendered the brideg at Mitchell impassable.
Floods rendered the brideg at Mitchell impassable.

Most popular articles

Advertisement



Queensland Country Life







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...