News 
 State News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Church weighs into mining vs farming debate 

Church weighs into mining vs farming debate

16 Jul, 2009 02:05 PM
THE mining versus agriculture debate has been ratcheted up this week by Darling Downs church leaders worried about its impact on affected communities.

Bishop of the Western Region, Anglican Diocese of Brisbane, Rob Nolan, Presbytery Minister Uniting Church in Australia (Downs Presbytery), Sharon Kirk, and executive officer, Social Justice Commission, Catholic Diocese of Toowoomba, Dr Mark Copland, see it as a "social justice" issue that is troubling many of their parishioners.

A joint statement underscores how they stand in solidarity with those farmers who fear for their security and future way of life.

Likewise, the representatives of southern Queensland's Anglican, Catholic and Uniting churches also acknowledge the contribution of mining and the generation of electricity throughout the region.

It's a sign of the sensitivity of an issue that, to date, has won little sympathy on the part of the Bligh Government.

The Bishop of the Anglican community's Western Region, Rob Nolan, said: "People say the church should not get involved in these things, but if the church does not get involved, then it becomes irrelevant.

"The church is 'people' and while we are political, we are not party-political."

Bishop Nolan believes the heart of the debate centres on the lack of government policy for making the best use of the State's natural resources, underscoring an increasing feeling of "inequality and powerlessness" on behalf of affected communities.

Catholic church spokesperson Dr Mark Copland makes the point that the issue continues to be raised by parishioners, notably at Jandowae, Chinchilla, Clifton and Allora, where the impact of proposed mining activity on prime agricultural land continues to top the agenda in each diocese.

"This is something they are all very concerned about," he said.

Presbytery Minister for the Uniting Church, Sharon Kirk, says there is another "sleeper issue" to consider, namely global food shortages.

Minister Kirk believes there needs to be greater dialogue with govern-ment officials, requiring a "big picture" plan for land use by getting more "round table" discussions between the State Government, farmers and miners.

Lobby group FutureFood Queens-land is calling on Natural Resources Minister Steven Robertson to "urgently introduce" a moratorium on new mining and gas operations across the State's cropping lands.

In the meantime, its co-chairman, Geoff Hewitt, has welcomed the commitment made by Premier Bligh, Deputy Premier Lucas, and Minister Robertson to undertake a regional development planning process aimed at guiding the development of the State's resources.

"We have been calling on the Government to initiate a planning process for some time, so it was good to receive that commitment from the State's leaders in writing from Minister Robertson early this week," Mr Hewitt said.

He stressed, however, that energy companies were continuing their push into quality farmland, suggesting the planning process would take too long to prevent major loss of farms.

"Only two percent of the State's land area is prime farmland and it is under threat of destruction. Urgent action is needed in the form of a moratorium," Mr Hewitt said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
There is both an ethical issue here and an environmental issue, as well as a long-term economic issue. People's lives stand to be distrupted. Farmland and rivers stand to be destroyed. Twenty years of profit will destroy a thousand years of productive farming income. By none of these measures is coal mining under productive land, or rivers, justifiable, or sensible. Denis
Posted by Denis Wilson, 16/07/2009 6:18:07 PM, on Queensland Country Life
I am concerned that across the country one vital resource is played off against another. In these play-offs mining is a frequent player. Not only does scarce arable land become collateral damage but so does our precious water. Can I just encourage all those campaigning locally to join with ever larger groups and alliances. And I don't mean merely industry groups. So many of us are fighting locally who are just plain citizens. Let's get the numbers - across the political, social, geographic and economic divides - in ways those who govern us can comprehend.
Posted by Miss Eagle, 16/07/2009 9:11:12 PM, on Queensland Country Life
The church should keep to saving souls and not interfering with Turnbull's mining mates!
Posted by Tigerdicky, 17/07/2009 8:53:52 AM, on Queensland Country Life
It is vitally important that as 'Miss Eagle' wisely says we need to organise and collectively show our opposition to further degradation of prime agricultural areas by mining companies. The Greens tried to amend a bill in NSW recently that was not supported by Nile's crusading circus and the one shot no-wonders Shooters' Party. As concerned citizens let's ask the Nationals to introduce these amendments so there's a bit more favourable support, rather than petty politics. Those in power need to be regularly shown the massive dissatisfaction out there. And we need to generate and maintain public awareness and action in the cities so that our 'leaders' know the widespread concerns and issues many people have with mining and exploring such productive areas. By joining up with larger groups and pressuring others, such as those in power we can have a future where long term farming isn't threatened by silly and foolish short term mining interests.
Posted by brett sanders, 17/07/2009 5:25:34 PM, on Queensland Country Life
We are all stewards of our land for future generations. Because of this fact we should pass the land on in as good or better condition than when our stewardship began. Prime agricultural land should never be mined. If the land is mined, then it is clearly a case of environmental vandalism.
Posted by greg, 19/07/2009 9:32:53 PM, on Queensland Country Life
Access to and use of the world's natural resources is always difficult as new knowledge (especially from below the ground) generates new opportunities for society. As humanity progresses, we and all people throughout our world all use more energy and we are still not capable of providing that at low cost without mining and burning coal. While empathising with farming people, we must all move on and though humans do not like change, it is inevitable. There have to be compensations paid by the users of the energy and though I have no knowledge of the Qld mining laws, that must be a fact. We are only temporary inhabitants of our world and should not stop progress that future people will benefit from, and that benefit comes from creation of greater wealth now for capital investment for our children and grandchildren to use.
Posted by Mike, 29/10/2009 12:16:24 PM, on Queensland Country Life

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Bishop of the Western Region, Anglican Diocese of Brisbane, Rob Nolan (centre) beside executive officer, Social Justice Commission, Catholic Diocese of Toowoomba, Dr Mark Copland (left) and Presbytery Minister Uniting Church in Australia (Downs Presbytery), Sharon Kirk.
Bishop of the Western Region, Anglican Diocese of Brisbane, Rob Nolan (centre) beside executive officer, Social Justice Commission, Catholic Diocese of Toowoomba, Dr Mark Copland (left) and Presbytery Minister Uniting Church in Australia (Downs Presbytery), Sharon Kirk.

Most popular articles

Advertisement



Queensland Country Life







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...