News 
 State News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Anti-pipe protesters would rather send water to Adelaide: Holding 

Anti-pipe protesters would rather send water to Adelaide: Holding

11/08/2008 3:56:00 PM
Water Minister Tim Holding has today claimed that opponents of the Brumby Government's Water Plan would rather send water to Adelaide than to Melbourne.

The claim is sure to anger Victorian irrigators who fear losing allocations in order to supply Melbourne with water under the State Government's pipe plan.

Mr Holding says the Liberal/National Coalition and protest group 'Plug the Pipe' have shown they are not interested in providing water security for all Victorians.

The also argue that the pipe will exacerbate the problems being experienced in South Australia, where thousands of people protested on the weekend to save the lower lakes.

"The Lower Lakes of the Murray River need over 1000 billion litres just to survive," he said.

"This is water that is just not available so for people to try to link a pipeline that will provide water security to Melbourne to the current state of the Lower Lakes is downright dishonest.

"Last week the protestors said we were building a white elephant and today the project is responsible for damaging the future of the Lower Lakes of the Murray River. They cannot have it both ways."

Mr Holding said stressed rivers, including the Murray River, and farmers would share in 350 billion litres a year as a result of the $2 billion Food Bowl Modernisation Project, while Melbourne would receive 75 billion litres of water savings from the project.

Mr Holding said that the environmental approvals process for the Sugarloaf Pipeline is the most rigorous ever undertaken for a pipeline in Victorian history.

"An independent panel considered all potential environmental impacts including any downstream impact on the Goulburn River and has given the project the green light," Mr Holding said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
When Water Minister Holding says, "An independent panel considered all potential environmental impacts, including any downstream impact on the Goulburn River..." and so on. I, as a Victorian voter, need to trust the judgement of our democratically elected government, unless of course some person delivers unto us clear evidence to the contrary. Whilst people may have differing opinions about water delivery, to date, not one Victorian citizen, to the best of my knowledge, has actually shown that the government's decision is incorrect.

The well publicised and organised 'political' group, campaigning under the banner, "Plug the Pipe" has not to the best of my knowledge produced any evidence to show that Premier Brumby's government erred in their water plan decision. And I have discovered no evidence from the Victorian parliament's Liberal/National opposition to show that the government erred, nor have I seen a better workable alternative plan presented by them. As interest groups go, the "plug the pipe people" have gained for themselves a great deal of attention, especially by their cheap, childish denigration of our well respected Premier, and the question we need to ask, "Can we trust them to take them seriously"? "Or are they trying to damage our well respected system of government?"

Throughout Australian contemporary history, individuals forming into organised bodies that share political goals have always worked to influence public policy decision making. We, as individuals, living in our democratic society, with iconic freedom of speech, keep our elected members of parliament on the 'straight and narrow'. But we also have to make our government work to deliver good outcomes, in order to maintain the very values we seemingly all cherish. As a good society, by global standards, we cannot afford serious social dislocation and division over something as fundamental as water and unless the opponents can come up with a superior plan we should all get on with the current one.

Ralf Kluin

Posted by Ralf Kluin on 12/08/2008 6:55:57 PM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

13/11/2008 | Cattle are getting a bad rap these days, so it's refreshing to see Britain's venerable National Trust getting into the business of "conservation cows".
S&L Advertising
 
S&L Subscriptions
 
Horse Deals Australia
 
You need cash
 
Rural Bookshop
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...