News 
 State News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 Finance 
 Bank Watch: back to the future 

Bank Watch: back to the future

05 Jan, 2012 10:10 AM
AN aggressive 1980s campaign against banking foreclosures - Bank Watch - will be relaunched in Queensland by North West Queensland mayor and landowner, John Wharton.

The campaign, due to begin in February, will unite the rural community behind farmers suffering crippling debt.

It will devise strategies to stop foreclosures, quarantine debt to speed recovery, and help banks and their farming customers agree on joint debt strategies.

The Richmond Mayor is the public face of farming foreclosure in Queensland after the Commonwealth Bank subsidiary, Bank West, sent receivers to take control of his family holdings at Richmond and Einasleigh two months ago.

He will address an inaugural meeting of the new Queensland lobby group in February.

Since news of Mr Wharton's plight was broken by Queensland Country Life, he has been swamped by calls from landholders concerned about their own financial vulnerability.

"I will talk to the meeting about receivership, what farmers should do to avoid it and what to do if it occurs," he said.

Bank Watch was formed in South Australia in 1988, after years of drought on the Eyre Peninsula left local wheat farmers heavily burdened by debt.

Public meetings led to a stake-out by campaigners at a highly publicised mortgagees' sale of properties at Ceduna and Cungena. The group campaigned to allow heavily indebted farmers to be protected from foreclosure until they were free to leave at a time of their own choosing.

Mr Wharton said Queensland Bank Watch would not target banks, but inform landholders of their rights, offer advice, work co-operatively and develop strategies to avoid the forced sale of rural property.

"It will help people to be better at finance," he said.

"They will be better prepared in their dealings with banks and more readily understand the documents and statements they receive. We are good business managers, but it is still possible to be shafted because of your finances.

"In South Australia it was the same process we face today in the North West and in Queensland as a whole," he said.

"Down there, Bank Watch stopped the process, but up here, we are still recovering from 2009. Many people are worried about their debt. I say to them to go and talk to their banks to look for a restructure of their debt.

"People talk about the good season and the high prices, but if you look for a comparison with the price of farm inputs, we need a lot more than $2 a kilogram. We'd need $3.50 or $4 a kilo to be on par with the rising price of a Toyota or a kilometre of fencing.

"We need to see the return on whole cows at more than $3 a kilo.

"The prices aren't there and that is why today even the biggest cattle operations return no more than a 1 percent margin."

The proposed Queensland model would be open to all interested parties.

It would provide counselling, negotiate deals on behalf of clients, and renegotiate and restructure farm debt packages.

In some cases, Bank Watch would lobby financiers to park part of a farmer's liability to enable the farming enterprise to recover.

"In too many cases, banks seem to operate on the assumption that their clients will win lotto tomorrow," Mr Wharton said.

"They have clients $5 million in debt who can service a debt of no more than $3m.

"The same people have a property worth $3m and the banks have no strategy to help them resolve the situation in ways that are mutually beneficial.

"There are options. You can park a parcel of that debt and set about dealing with the liability one parcel at a time."

Mr Wharton said a second strategy to increase farm profits through online bartering would be launched by a group of North West Queensland beef producers at the same time.

He said the scheme, to eliminate the need for cash payments by trading stock for agistment on common terms, would enable producers to reduce their tax liability.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Here's a thought .. perhaps don't gear up so high in the first place!!

Ultimately it is greed that drives people to over extend in the first place .. we all know the rule of thumb out there .. 3-in-10 years will be good yet you continue to bank on 5.

Posted by frenchie, 6/01/2012 8:37:10 AM, on Queensland Country Life
If there are "farmers suffering crippling debt", perhaps the best thing for them and the lending bank is foreclosure. Farming definitely is not and should not be sheltered workshop industry. We want strong street-wise competitive operators, not those who borrow all they can without a nanosecond's thought for the consequences except their mistaken belief that the basic laws of finance do not apply to them. Many of them are operating where wise men would not consider.
Posted by Bushie Bill, 6/01/2012 8:42:31 AM, on Queensland Country Life
Bushie bill, real farmers labour under the assumption that we are in an industry that is vital to all australians. Food security is no joke and yet while the rest of the world "get it" people like you are happy to let your farming intellectual capacity in australia go to the wall! What is your solution? Do you really think leaving the "farm" in the hands of foreign multinationals is the answer? A tip for you BB, nobody can do what the farmers in Australia can do - all we ask is that our faith in the public of australia is reciprocated.
Posted by hungry Farmer, 6/01/2012 6:18:52 PM, on Queensland Country Life
So, hungry farmer, you say "nobody can do what the farmers in Australia can do". Do you thus also conclude that the so-call current wave of foreign ownership will end, as it has done in other eras, with those same current foreign buyers failing and returning the land to Australian farmers that you say are the only ones in the world who can work Australian land? Or are you saying by inference that the new owners will succeed by employing Australian farmers and workers to manage their farms. If you mean this, what does it say about Australian farmers and workers so-called individualistic traits?
Posted by Bushie Bill, 9/01/2012 11:12:09 AM, on Queensland Country Life
You have missed the point entirely BB, so I will try to spell it out to you - Australian farmers are providing food security for Australian people. This will not necessarily be the case if the land is owned by foreigners. This is the job that no other can do! Is this clear enough or do I need to draw pictures as well? Stop word-playing and get to the real issue at hand, would you.
Posted by hungry farmer, 10/01/2012 11:15:15 AM, on Queensland Country Life
By the way BsBill, hungry farmer and I are two seperate entities.I do like him though,don't you think?Oops, stupid question.You don't do you?
Posted by Hungry?, 10/01/2012 2:26:43 PM, on Queensland Country Life
hungry farmer, the food security argument is a crock of crap (recognised as such by anyone other than a halfwit), argued by the intellectually challenged and the didactically deprived, and the god-forsaken arse-out-of-their-pants farmers seeking yet another special consideration to allow them to continue, at a higher level, to rip off long-suffering Australian consumers.

And hf, it will be a cold day in hell before I miss a point. Why don't farmers, if they so damned good at what they do, simply get on and do it, and stop bothering good people with all the whingeing? There is a limit.


Posted by Bushie Bill, 10/01/2012 6:44:56 PM, on Queensland Country Life
someone has been playing with their thesarsaus! If we line up the cost of basic foods in 1st world countries - aus is the cheapest. If we line up the returns to farmers in all developed countries - aus is again cheapest! 12 billion was given to car manufacturing in Aus in the last ten years for job security - why is farming so "on the nose" in regard to support by govt? If the govt will not support agriculture then why should the population be getting such cheap, secure, healthy food? Perhaps Bushie Bill, you are not so "bushie" after all. Thanks for all the support........
Posted by hungry farmer, 11/01/2012 10:03:04 AM, on Queensland Country Life
Well Bill, we would all like to "simply get on and do it" but we have these so called intellectually gifted know-it-alls such as yourself and your soon to be bride, Nicky that seem to know our job better than we do!(Well, at least in your little minds)So but out and we will.

And he calls us RARA's!

Posted by Hungry?, 11/01/2012 10:33:46 AM, on Queensland Country Life
H-boy, do you know what a RARA is? From your post, it appears not. Another thing, H-boy, if I can prevent you from doing your job well by sending an occasional constructively critical post, what does that say about your resolve and determination?

"If we line up the returns to farmers in all developed countries - aus is again cheapest!" says hf. Hf, that is nonsensical and meaningless. How can a return be cheapest? Wtf does that mean?

Posted by Bushie Bill, 11/01/2012 7:01:17 PM, on Queensland Country Life
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

Advertisement



Queensland Country Life







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...