News 
 National Rural News 
 Wool 
 General 
 McLachlan threatens more legal action 

McLachlan threatens more legal action

22 May, 2008 11:42 AM
Former wool leader Ian McLachlan is threatening more legal action.

Various defamation cases are being proposed, the latest against Australian Wool Growers Association (AWGA) president Martin Oppenheimer after the New England woolgrower made public statements questioning Mr McLachlan’s private interest in the breech clip technology being developed by Australian Wool Innovation.

The case stems from an AWGA media statement made in early March in which Mr Oppenheimer stated; "AWI has persisted with McLachlan’s 'pet project' mulesing clips, which despite technical and animal welfare issues, have received millions in funding. McLachlan admitted at the 2007 AWI Annual General Meeting that the clips had problems."

Mr Oppenheimer then speculated that the reasons behind AWI fighting pain relief, yet supporting mulesing clips was political and noted that Ian McLachlan and fellow AWI Director Chris Abell were "named as inventors on the patent register for the clips."

"This conflict of interest cannot stand and may have a serious effect on our international wool trade," Mr Oppenheimer said in the statement.

It is unsure whether the legal action against Mr Oppenheimer will be funded by Mr McLachlan or by AWI.

"If grower levies are being used to fund this action it is a breech of the Federal Government statutory funding agreement and I can tell you the Federal Minister agrees with me," Mr Oppenheimer said.

He is currently seeking legal advice regarding the proposed legal action.

"Mr McLachlan can do what he likes, unfortunately this action won’t sell any more wool nor increase the price. I have been inundated with calls of support. It is amazing the depth of feeling against Mr McLachlan in this industry," he added.

AWI stated this week that it had no comment to make on any private actions.

It is understood the latest defamation case is not the only legal action initiated by Mr McLachlan this year.

Both the ABC and the Swedish television program "Kalla Fakta" are in the book after allegedly misrepresenting the facts when suggesting AWI had "bribed" someone from the Swedish current affairs program.

ABC Rural national head Leigh Radford confirmed lawyers acting for Ian McLachlan had written to the ABC on his behalf and lawyers acting for AWI had also written to the ABC on its behalf but there was no case as yet.

AWI spent over seven million dollars on legal fees and public relations expertise when battling the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) over the issue of mulesing.

Ian McLachlan led the way, personally handing PETA co-founder Ingrid Newkirk a legal challenge during the filming of a 60 Minutes story in 2004.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
This sounds very much like a script from a Monty Python movie.

On one side we have the Peoples Front of Judea (AWI) infighting against the Judean Peoples Front (AWGA) instead of a united attack against the common enemy: The Romans (PETA).

Posted by Brian Cohen, 23/05/2008 8:02:23 AM
The implication that Ian was motivated to hold fast to the clips solution even when it was failing technically, economically and politicially because he was the inventor of the clip, could be libellous if it was implied that it was based on his desire for financial gain or motivated by personal or professional pride in his invention.

If Ian can prove that he was holding out because he genuinely believed this was the best solution for the industry, despite its apparent failure on other fronts - technical, economic, political - then he has a case.

He is an experienced litigant so we can assume he has a strong case and is not simply using threats of legal action to suppress dissent.

It is unfortunate that he hands over the helm of the industry and leaves trailing legal writs when we should be focussed on his contribution.

It would be instructive to compare the state of the industry when he took over to its condition today.

Only then will we appreciate Mr McLachlan's true contribution.

Posted by Michael Kiely, 23/05/2008 9:05:20 AM
Nothing changes in the wool industry - I hope Ian had as many sleepless nights as I did - the price for wanting to to serve wool growers is often very high.

The King has died - long live the King!

Posted by Dorber's Musing, 23/05/2008 11:48:16 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

Advertisement



Queensland Country Life







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...