News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Wentworth scientist doubts water buyback 

Wentworth scientist doubts water buyback

22/05/2008 1:16:00 PM
Farmers should be paid up front for the value of their water and be given three years to adjust to slimmer water sharing rules rather than have the government buying allocations over 10 years, according to Wentworth Group economist, Professor Mike Young.

Professor Young told the ABC this week he has major reservations about the Government's plan to spend more than $3 billion buying back licences from farmers for the environment.

He said it would only see rural communities "collapse, and collapse slowly over a decade".

He said many farmers would sell their water and move out without and reinvestment in irrigation systems in country areas.

Rather than investing in the water market, Professor Young said the Federal Government must drive change themselves by paying farmers the value of their water entitlements and give them three years to adjust to a new water sharing regime.

He said while some may put that money into superannuation or retire, he predicts many farmers will reinvest it into their farms and irrigation systems.

"The alternative is to have a government gorilla in the market grabbing at every piece of water that comes on the market," Professor Young said.

"If that happens farmers will have a market that is dysfunctional."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
With farmers in debt, banks will now force them to off-load their water and it will go to what it terms "high value" farming ventures, mostly owned by Managed Investment Schemes, equity trusts, and super funds and the Government.

REDUCING FARM VALUES by removing water from titles, they have now the legal power to take your water for environmental flows or to cater for the mass immigration planned for Australia of 50 million by 2050, and they need your water for the cities.

The consequences of this will be tragic for rural Australia, but the major political Parties are so controlled by the “Globalists” that they will not save you.

Posted by Diane Teasdale on 23/05/2008 7:45:27 AM
I've said before the fair and equitable way to solve the problem NOW is to take an accross the board 10% of all water entitlements in the Murray Darling Basin, returning 1000GL to the system.

No net cost to anyone.

An immediate solution.

Do something, time is running out!!

Posted by GT on 23/05/2008 11:31:54 AM
The solution is controllng allocations in the system, not buying entitlements.

I tend to agree with GT and that if we take an across the board reduction in entitlements and pay irrigators a fair market price for them and then after that let irrigators sort out their requirements in the market place.

It is very important that control of allocation is the only way to immediately put water back into the river.

Posted by Phillip on 23/05/2008 12:57:58 PM
Good on you Diane, was wondering if there were any other real Aussies left out there who can see through this constant well maintained smoke haze our highly paid politicians keep sprouting.

Don't we know it...it's the budget we all had to have mainly to keep every Australian well placed in the big investment circles?

When do Bankers, Politicians and Multinational Company bosses ever take a drop in pay?

When do the banks ever make a loss or a reality-related drop in profits?

Their cozy end of the deal keeps escalating nicely year by year.

When are the politicians going to let them have some flack and stop taking it all out of middle and poor Australian family purses?

About time the pensioners and the plethora of family farmers soon to leave the land teamed up, seeing as they are now clearly regarded as third rate citizens.

Whatever happens with future water allocations, these dunderheaded committees and their 'outcomes' must in the first instance be fair to the people running smaller operations on the land or it will send more than a very negative message reverberating all around Australia.

Most clear-headed country people have already had more than a gut full of these metro-run parties from both political camps.

Parties who pander to certain elements that only squeal when it hits them in the high earning investment hip pocket.

But what do these people actually produce that is a concrete asset?

Take a crash course in Chinese; it's well regarded in the right circles.

Might also help you get a job with some of our new land tenants!

Posted by all bloody allocations on 23/05/2008 3:10:54 PM
I have followed recent articles and developments regarding our Government’s Water Buy Back Plan with interest, including the recently acquired 35,000 mega litres @ $1428 per mega litre for $50 Million.

The plan adopted is ill conceived, and will not bring about the desired result and importantly it wastes a considerable percentage of surplus GDP.

I have been involved with irrigation of broad acre wheat growing for a number of years, and have been trialling drip irrigation with great success.

I first proposed to Malcolm Turnbull and recently to our current Minister for Energy and Water Ms. Penny Wong as follows: Rather than purchase water from irrigators – thus decreasing agricultural output - subsidize on farm installations of modern irrigation technology to the tune of 75% - and ‘force’ Australia into the 21st century – as opposed to our current wasteful method of Flood Irrigation.

The advantages are numerous, but to name a few:

• Water savings of up to 60% per Hectare for Wheat Cotton and Rice growing

• 10 to 15% yield increase in productivity from same area of irrigation

• Fuel savings (due to decreases in travel over the paddock)

• Substantial decrease in the use of fungicides and pesticides

• 5 to 8 times the increase in environmental flows - as opposed to those planned to be achieved by the current “$3.1 billion Buy Back Plan”

• Increase in profits and taxation.

I have written twice to our water minister Ms. Wong without result.

I would be pleased to provide any reference material you desire, in order for you to verify and/or research my assertions.

Feel free to discuss the matter with me any time

Soren Lunoe

C & L Patoral Co Pty Ltd

C/o Turon Gates

Turon Gates Road

‘Capertee NSW 2846

www.turongates.com Soren@turongates.com

O42 727 0416

02 635690142

Posted by Soren Lunoe on 28/05/2008 8:26:48 AM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

11/12/2008 | Farm lobby groups will decide next week whether the future of farm representation will stay as it is or be broadened to bring in the big end of town.
QCL Subscriptions
 
QCL Rate Card
 
Rural Bookshop
 
QCL - Mail Order Cataloge
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...