The Federal Government's water buy back policies and an unrelenting focus on the plight of the Lower Lakes in South Australia is pitting north against south in the Murray Darling Basin, according to former Deputy Prime Minister, John Anderson.
His comments come on the back of a new $400m offer from the Government to buy water in the northern part of the basin, and today's purchase by the NSW Government, of the iconic Warrego river property, Toorale Station, at Bourke.
Mr Anderson is now watching the water reforms in the Basin from his Liverpool Plains farm, following his retirement from Parliament last year.
He said the ad hoc approach the Labor Government was taking to buying water is hurting communities and the environment and will have major implications for Australia's ability to produce food.
He said it is also pitting north against south as the Government, Greens and even some Opposition MPs talk up the need to get water to the Lower Lakes, while farmers north of Menindee, who are also going without, are made to look like "the devil themselves".
Federal Minister for Water, Penny Wong, announced the second phase of the Government's water buyback scheme on Monday, this time focussing on purchasing northern water entitlements - with $400m on the table.
Senator Wong will next week call for tenders to sell water to the Government, restricting the offer to only northern NSW and Queensland.
"We are facing the combined effects of climate change, years of over-allocation and drought," Senator Wong said.
"And we know that, to address this, what we have to do is purchase water entitlements to return to the river."
But Mr Anderson said the Government's approach is all over the shop, taking no notice of the science dictating where the over-allocated "hot spots" in the Basin actually exist and causing immense frustration and hurt throughout the basin, but especially in the north.
"I think this has all been prompted more by drought and an over-reaction in the cities with this over-simplistic idea that somehow you can send water from the north down and it will flush through the system," Mr Anderson said.
"There is real concern from irrigators in this area that the Government is going to close districts down rather than, as specified in the national water initiative, focus on and address the hot spots first."
* Extract from a full report in this week's Fairfax rural newspapers.