News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Turnbull slams Abbott's carbon plan 

Turnbull slams Abbott's carbon plan

09 Feb, 2010 06:32 AM
THE former opposition leader Malcolm Turnbull has labelled Tony Abbott's climate change policy as ''a recipe for fiscal recklessness on a grand scale'' that would increase taxes and fail to reduce emissions.

Speaking on the legislation for the emissions trading scheme in Parliament yesterday, a defiant Mr Turnbull said he would cross the floor to vote for the scheme that he had helped shape.

The Coalition under Mr Abbott has abandoned support for the ETS and announced a rival plan where businesses that choose to cut their emissions would be paid incentives out of a taxpayer-funded pool worth $11.7 billion over 10 years.

''Having the government pick projects for subsidy is a recipe for fiscal recklessness on a grand scale, and there will always be a temptation for projects to be selected for their political appeal,'' Mr Turnbull said.

''In short, having the government pay for emissions abatement, as opposed to the polluting industries themselves, is a slippery slope which can only result in higher taxes and more costly and less effective abatement of emissions.

''I say this as a member and former leader of a political party whose core values are a commitment to free markets and free enterprise.''

Mr Abbott's policy claims to reduce emissions by 5 per cent by 2020, the same target as the ETS, but Mr Turnbull said it was not enough just to support the cuts. ''You must also deliver a strong, credible policy framework that will deliver them.''

He said without a cap on emissions and a price on carbon, there would be either no new industry investment in Australia or there would be more dirty industry built ''because they are more profitable in a world where there is no price on carbon emissions''.

Mr Turnbull implied it was improper to label the ETS a tax, as the opposition was doing, because it was not designed to raise net revenue for the government. Rather, the revenue would be returned to households and businesses as compensation and transitional assistance.

He noted the 1.1 per cent effect the ETS would have on inflation paled against the 2.8 per cent increase caused by the introduction of the GST.

The speech failed to stir sentiment in the Coalition. Only four MPs - Joe Hockey, Jamie Briggs, Petro Georgiou and Russell Broadbent - sat in the house for all of it.

Buoyed by the latest Fairfax poll that showed support for Kevin Rudd and the ETS sliding, Mr Abbott spent the morning at a dry-cleaning business in Queanbeyan to empathise with the licensee, Jason Webb, about the effect of the ETS on his annual $15,000 power bill.

''Even on the government's own figures, he's going to be faced with about a $3000-a-year slug,'' Mr Abbott said.

The ETS contains no direct compensation for small businesses to help them with power bills, just a fund from which they can apply for more energy-efficient equipment and other alterations to cut energy costs.

Mr Abbott was admonished by the government for being stuck in the past after suggesting ''housewives'' doing the ironing would also feel the pinch.

Mr Abbott made the comment while posing for the cameras and ironing a shirt.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1



RELATED COVERAGE

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
The flim-flam man, without principle and without a beacon (except the good Cardinal), a man with no vision but prepared to say and do anything to win, in true macho style, versus a man of great intellect, foresight and lofty ambitions for his country, a man in the Churchill style. It should be obvious, but unfortunately intelligence is not a prerequisite to gain the right to vote, and thus the hillbillies and the hayseeds, the ignorant, the ill-informed, the selfish and just plain stupid, the people who truly prove the rule of the lowest common denominator, rule the day. How depressing. However, all is not lost. The Australian people have a good record in coming to their senses before committing political suicide. We were smart enough to pick Latham as a disaster and a fraud, so perhaps we will be smart enough to recognise Abbott as another Latham, without the brains but with the cynicism. We must always be optimistic, and fight ignorance at every level. As is perhaps unsurprising in Australia, due to its history, ignorance is a badge of honour for far too many people. Go into a small town farming area pub on Friday afternoon, and you will witness unlimited quantities of it.
Posted by Bushie Bill, 9/02/2010 9:07:07 AM, on The Land
Do you hate everyone Bushie, or did you break down on a country road somewhere and no-one stopped to help you??
Posted by mark2, 9/02/2010 10:28:37 AM, on The Land
No one cares what you think Malcolm. Get some counselling and get on with your life.
Posted by Qlander, 9/02/2010 10:33:09 AM, on Queensland Country Life
Bushie Bill – Do you feel better now ?? Good. Now take your offensive elitist bigotry and go away.
Posted by Pub Talk, 9/02/2010 10:51:13 AM, on The Land
Bushy bill: Intelligence and education come on many levels and in many forms. My brother in law is an endocrinologist and the most intelligent man I know. Yet the prospect of assembling a child's cot his wife had bought from IKEA sent him into a complete panic attack. Some years ago I employed an Aboriginal man whose reading skills were limited to comic books. There is a waterhole on my property which is a well-known fishing spot. One day while we were there I noticed him scouting around amongst tumbledown boulders that lead up to a small hill overlooking the waterhole. He came back to me and reported that someone had been here five days ago. A man, an old woman and a child, most likely a girl. He tried to show me that it was obvious that the woman was old because you could see where the man had stopped a help her up the rocks. And the child was most likely a girl because she had taken an easier route than a boy would. I thought I could track a bit. But in spite of what he tried to show me I could see nothing.
Posted by Qlander, 9/02/2010 11:38:26 AM, on Queensland Country Life
Later I mentioned the incident in the local pub, and a neighbour enquired as to the date the Aboriginal man thought that people had been there. He then went on to explain that he had taken his elderly mother and daughter to that waterhole on that exact date. I realised then that when it came to tracking I was at the ‘see spot run stage’ while this Aboriginal man had a Ph.D. in literature. In closing I will say this: I've never ever explained a difficult concept to someone or changed their thinking on something by engaging in sarcasm or insulting their intelligence.
Posted by Qlander, 9/02/2010 11:39:12 AM, on Queensland Country Life
Malcolm knows who butters his bread, the big end of town. The riff raff, the average mums and dads have a responsibility to finance the ETS so Malcolm can fulfill his destiny, being that of a blue blood intellectual with authority over the minions.
Posted by The Turnbul faction of the Labor party, 9/02/2010 1:03:38 PM, on The Land
Well said Bushie Bill!
Posted by Tigerdicky, 9/02/2010 1:43:02 PM, on The Land
Me thinks Bushie Bill is actually Malcolm's pseudonym. It is easy to tell as they are both arrogant block-heads, full of their own importance while peddling divisive nonsense.
Posted by Dexter M, 10/02/2010 6:14:52 AM, on The Land
Yes, sad but true Bushie Bill.
Posted by Dave, 10/02/2010 7:00:00 AM, on The Land
1 | 2 | 3  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Malcolm Turnbull
Malcolm Turnbull
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
08 February, 2010
POLL
Q: One year on from the Black Saturday bushfires, do you think governments are now conducting adequate preventative backburning?

Yes
(5.3%)

No
(89%)

Undecided
(5.7%)

Total Votes: 563
Poll Date: 07 February, 2010
BLOGS
07 February, 2010
SPECIAL FEATURES

Most popular articles

Ray White Rural Metromax
 
Pro-Tech
 
IRRIGATION CONFERENCE 2010
 
photo gallery
 
QCL Facebook
 
QCL Twitter


 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...