News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Killer carbon tax to hit farmers 

Killer carbon tax to hit farmers

11 Dec, 2008 12:03 PM
The Government will next week release a detailed discussion paper on the proposed emissions trading scheme to come into place a little over a year from now.

But the Opposition warns that agriculture is about to be hit with the equivalent of a killer tax from day one of the scheme, and says it's time farmers start making some noise.

Agriculture is not expected to feature too heavily when Federal Minister for Climate Change, Penny Wong, releases the Government's emission reduction targets because the sector won't be considered for coverage until 2013.

But the Opposition's Andrew Robb, who is helping leader Malcolm Turnbull on emissions trading, says leaving agriculture out of the scheme has farmers believing they won't be affected once it starts next year, which couldn't be further from the truth.

Mr Robb is off to America at the end of next week to investigate the merits of a voluntary carbon reduction scheme and see the mechanics of the Chicago Carbon Climate Exchange, which has been trading permits for emissions for several years he said.

He said he is bothered agriculture won't be considered to be part of the scheme from the start, and thinks the Government is rushing its introduction when there was clearly still a lot of design and research work needed.

"On the face of it it sounds like agriculture's not affected by an emissions trading scheme, but that's quite wrong," Mr Robb said.

"The cost of electricity going up will indirectly affect all agricultural industries.

"The estimate in the dairy industry, depending on the price of carbon at about $20 a tonne, is an impost somewhere between $50 million and $80m a year from day one, 2010, which is the equivalent of $6000 per dairy farm on average.

"That impost would have to be absorbed by the farmer, with no chance for offsets."

Mr Robb said this would cruel agriculture unnecessarily when there was a lot of evidence to suggest the opportunities for carbon abatement at the farm level are enormous.

"In the US they're even selling credits with farmers that undertake to rotate cows through fresh pasture for a season because it's been proven to reduce burping by up to 70pc."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size


comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
By far the biggest impact of a carbon trading scheme on Agriculture could be POSITIVE - because Agriculture is the only sector able to remove carbon directly from the atmosphere by way of photosynthesis. At last the politicians are starting to realise that there are 2 aspects to dealing with climate change, TECHNOLOGY and BIOLOGY. We must encourage our positive carbon-friendly farmers to play their part. If we can find billions for the car industry and millions for a soccer world cup bid, surely we can put some serious money into ensuring we have a planet to live on.
Posted by soil carbon, 11/12/2008 5:43:29 AM
You don't honestly think that Labor is interested in west of the Divide, do you? KRudd is only interested in the city vote and is beholden to the unions. Look at who forms Labor: John Robertson, George Campbell, Kevin Reynolds, Joe Tripodi, Wayne Swan, Julia Gillard. Why would they encourage agriculture in any form when we can get our food imported from China with its dubious record. Why do you think KRudd is pushing so hard for a free trade agreement? Why do you think KRudd is pushing for tax breaks and forestry MIS arrangements at the expense of ag. There is no way a food commodity based per ha gross margin is going to compete against tax offsets for forestry giving those schemes the sufficient ROI to enable purchases of prime ag land. No farmers unless you're the size of AACo will be able to compete. Drive the prices up, force food production out, import to cover the shortfall and watch the towns out west die off. Why do think there has been no credible investment in health, etc out west. Agriculture has been the sacrificial lamb for years. It started before Howard, who continued it, and continues today with Garrett and Wong. Has anyone heard anything else arising form signing Kyoto? What a dud that was. Something like this upcoming climate change tax has been on the cards for years. Where will those billions go? The myth of climate change is now just the excuse they need. 30,000 plus scientists have just signed a statement citing they don't believe in climate change. Think about it. Question everything.
Posted by mbh, 11/12/2008 7:06:19 AM
What a load of rubbish. Mr Robb is concerned about the impact of farmers - 11 years of Howard government did nothing. So the best he can do is jet off to America to get information that is freely availbale in Australia and online. Now he thinks the landholders should make some noise. Every time we tried to get a project through the AGO it was trampled by liberal bureaucrats. I know of a few who have tried to get farmers involved for years and have been met with resistance and denial by landholders and farmer groups. The CCX is a joke supported by its members with appalling prices and uncertain environmental outcomes. Mr Robb wants to go and look at volountary markets, how about having a look at Australia's and cleaning it up first, this voluntary market in Austrlaia is rife with rip offs and nobody wants to do anything about it, it is making a huge legacy for Australia. The Voluntary Carbon Standards (VCS) will not operate in Australia due to the federal government policy. Mr Robb should save our money and talk to a few people in Australia first. Other politicians are starting to wake up to what is going on and they did not leave Australia. sick of it
Posted by sickofit, 11/12/2008 9:35:58 AM
Would someone with an objective agricultural science background please publish some solid numbers on carbon and methane for grass-fed beef cattle. Then would NFF and other relevant organisations please take a strong position on behalf of its constituency on this. If we sit around waiting for the government to look after it we'll be ruined by default! They have no interest helping in rural Australia.
Posted by aj, 11/12/2008 10:17:03 AM
In the old days the forerunners of the green religion used to sacrifice animals and even their children to appease their gods. Now they are sacrificing economies and countries by way of carbon taxes to appease their gods, with about the same degree of zealotry. The result will be the same. No change to the climate.
Posted by Len, 11/12/2008 12:35:55 PM
What can I say, just another excuse for another tax which will do absolutely nothing except to open another goldmine for the Government. I have got to admit though, they don't miss a trick when it comes to taxing everyone everywhere. Terry.
Posted by Terry, 11/12/2008 8:42:44 PM
Not all our family is vegan as I am, but we all have healthy and tasty plant based foods. Our milk and cheese comes from soy. People scorn this diet, and it is not commercially endorsed, but all nutrients, except vitamin B12, are abundant without the animal fats. There is no need for high emissions, water use, and livestock as a source of food. Our government continues to greenwash the public, but does nothing about alternative energy OR food sources. We enjoy the tasty and natural foods. Not only this, but we can avoid many modern diseases and obesity.
Posted by vegan, 12/12/2008 7:43:03 AM
Does this brain dead government really think that the farmers produce enough carbon to be taxed on? Come on!
Posted by fred d, 9/04/2009 1:19:15 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Liberal MP Andrew Robb
Liberal MP Andrew Robb
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
11 December, 2008
POLL
Q: Should the Nationals split from the Coalition?

Yes
(48.8%)

No
(47%)

Undecided
(4.1%)

Total Votes: 606
Poll Date: 07 December, 2008

Most popular articles

Advertisement



Queensland Country Life







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...