Opinion 
 Blogs 
 The week observed  
 World turns true believers upside down 

World turns true believers upside down

In journalism there is nothing worse than interviewing someone with TB - True Believerism.

You know the type - no matter how fair and rational an argument may be, any criticism of a their ideological tilt is met with scorn and abuse and being branded as a stooge for the other side.

Most commonly such characters are found working in the press offices of politicians, spending their hours abusing journalists who write critically of the actions of their party, or deliberately hindering the media's quest to hold such public figures to account.

Such characters have variously branded me a Labor stooge, a Liberal supporter, a Nationals sympathiser, a fascist, a communist and a capitalist pig - the combination of which means I'm either a well-balanced personality or must be doing something right in my job.

But the rapidly changing world is turning traditional ideology upside down, leaving TB sufferers supporting a brand and not a belief.

Take for instance the events of the past week with the financial meltdown in the United States. Some stubborn Republicans and Democrats initially killed Bill to bail out cash-strapped banks, arguing that such intervention contravened their belief in free-market principles. Never mind that free-market principles have put not just the banks, but the people of the western world at risk.

Thankfully that Bill has now been passed, albeit with many hailing it as the death of capitalism. Hyperbole yes, given that pure capitalism, like pure communism or pure any other ideology, has been dead for a long time.

Take for example the nature of land title, a bastion of the capitalist system - Australians have willingly accepted such interventionist Government regulation of land use that it is now not far short of a communist system. Short of dictating which crops to grow (although Professor Garnaut's kangaroo concept was a step in that direction), planning rules dictate exactly what each parcel of land can be used for - unless of course you own a coal mine, in which case the Government will turn a blind eye to wherever you want to park it.

In Australia we have such a love of rules that libertarians lament the loss of personal freedoms.

But such regulations are exactly what is saving our banks from collapse where others have fallen.

Rather than finding a new ideology to solve the world's ills, the real challenge is finding the right balance between the counter-veiling forces of regulation and personal liberity.

As the saying goes, all things in moderation, even moderation itself.

Oh, and while we're dishing out the wisdom of proverbs, the bankers on Wall Street should have listened to my mother who liked to say you can't live on the never never, or you'll end up on Shanks's pony.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Yes well there was not a lot of balance between regulation and freedom when wheat growers were stripped of their marketing system and there will be a day of reckoning.
Posted by Realist on 8/10/2008 6:11:58 PM
Michael, As a still-cynical journalist myself, I appreciate the shot at ideologues who believe the righteousness of their cause allows them to be rude and, worse, boring. We have been campaigning for 3 years to create the free market for soil carbon credits - so farmers can sell what carbon they grow in their soils and, at the same time, prepare their land for climate change and reduce their emissions. In the course of pursuing these goals - save the soil, save the family farm, save the planet - we have encountered TB, oodles of it, from well-meaning people who have no idea what's going on, like Dylan's Mr Jones. Our dilemma is to be caught between the old paradigm of soil dynamics dominated by chemistry and the emerging field of soil biology. Politicians and farmers love us. Because we offer them hope, and a solution. And we have no ulterior motive. My wife and I are woolgrowers and we have 'spent the kids' inheritance' to finance the campaign to get this issue on the national agenda. We aim to set up an industry association to represent farmers. The Carbon Farmers Association of Australia will be proposed at the 2008 Carbon Farming Conference at Orange, 17-20 November, 2008. Phone 02 6374 0329. This is the second conference of its kind in the world, the first being last years which we staged in Mudgee where 380 turned up from every state in Australia and New Zealand. We are aiming for 500-800 this year. There will be 2 major launches - of a trading scheme and a range of soil products - and the best farmers and scientists in the field. (We don't let anyone other than farmers and scientists to speak, because these events are part of our Soil Science Summits Series (4 staged so far) which bring farmers and scientists together to swap insights and learn from each other.)
Posted by Michael Kiely on 10/10/2008 4:45:24 PM
"In Australia we have such a love of rules that libertarians lament the loss of personal freedoms."....Yes, and forty years ago this wasn't so. Why the change? Why have people lost confidence in themselves and each other? I would say that it is because they have been told so many lies that they don't believe anybody any more. For this part of the blame must go to the Marxists in the education system. "But such regulations are exactly what is saving our banks from collapse where others have fallen."........Don't count your chickens yet. There are other wolves waiting to pounce, like the Current Account Deficit for example. And the loss of export income that would result if there is a downturn in the demand for coal and iron ore. The regulations which were protecting us from such collapses were removed by Hawke and Keating as soon as they were elected in 1983. We have now had two collapses since.
Posted by Ted O'Brien on 16/10/2008 6:35:52 AM
In Germany somewhere there is a town that kept on erecting new signs and constructing 'traffic calming' in an attempt to stop the number of crashes that were ever increasing. Apparently it became impossible to follow all of the directions, trying to, caused more crashes. They removed ALL of the signs and the traffic calmed down and the crashes almost stopped. Is there a lesson there?
Posted by Roger Crook on 17/10/2008 7:50:29 AM
I can relate to that - so-called 'traffic calming' islands only serve to frustrate me.
Posted by Michael Thomson on 17/10/2008 9:14:51 AM
why is there such a uproor about the tonnes of co2 emitted into the atmosphire - the more co2 the more trees take in and grow faster . co2 is 1.5 times heavier than air sinks and disperces in water releasing oxegen and the carbon sinks. the % co2 has not changed & is still.0249% of the atmosphire if it did not grassfires would not burn
Posted by hally on 18/10/2008 6:14:06 PM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Michael Thomson is the Editor of FarmOnline. He has previously worked as the Canberra Parliamentary Press Gallery correspondent for the Rural Press group of agricultural newspapers, and as a senior reporter with Queensland Country Life.

Q: Do you have confidence in the Rudd Government's ability to guide Australia through the current turbulent economic conditions?

Yes
(18.5%)

No
(74.6%)

Undecided
(6.9%)

Total Votes: 826
Poll Date: 5/10/2008

21/11/2008 | AWI's new board can only succeed in old battles by fighting in new ways.
QCL Subscriptions
 
QCL Rate Card
 
Horse Deals Australia
 
Rural Bookshop
 
QCL - Mail Order Cataloge
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...