Is the State Government's overhaul of local councils bad for democracy?
Or will it improve the delivery of services on the ground?
With 43pc of Queensland's local governments judged to be in a financially weak, very weak or distressed state, clearly something had to be done.
But the Australian Local Government Association says action was already being taken to improve internal council structures and to share resources and decision making at a regional level in order to improve financial sustainability.
But Premier Peter Beattie's decision has scuppered that process, leaving councils fearing amalgamation into new 'super shires'.
Mayors in the bush fear this will make it harder for remote land holders to access services and political representation, and centralises too much power with the state.
What do you think?